The Labor Department proposed Monday to change how employers show that they considered U.S. workers before sponsoring a foreign employee for permanent residence. The department’s announcement said the plan would strengthen recruitment and recordkeeping requirements, add safeguards after layoffs and eliminate an exception for certain occupations, including professional nurses and physical therapists. The rules would apply to labor certification, a step in many employer-sponsored green card cases.
The proposed rule was scheduled for publication Tuesday in the Federal Register, with 60 days for public comment. Employers would continue to follow the current rules while the department considers comments and decides whether to issue a final rule. The Washington Post reported that the proposal would be the first comprehensive revision of the program in nearly two decades.
What an employer must show
The Permanent Labor Certification program, often called PERM, applies to most employer-sponsored cases in two commonly used employment-based visa categories. An employer generally advertises a job and must show that there are insufficient available U.S. workers who meet the requirements for the position. The department also considers whether employing the foreign worker would adversely affect wages and working conditions for similarly employed U.S. workers. The rule’s preamble describes both tests and the statute behind them.
Under the proposal, employers would need to use recruitment practices designed to reach workers through current hiring channels. The department would revise minimum recruitment standards and broaden the requirements for giving workers notice of an application. Immigration law firm Fragomen said the changes would increase the duties of employers when recruiting and filing, as well as the department’s scrutiny of applications and supporting documents.
A labor certification clears a step for the employer. The employer still generally needs to file an immigrant petition with U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, and the worker must satisfy other requirements before obtaining permanent residence. Reuters reported that large technology companies and outsourcing firms use PERM to sponsor employees who are working in the United States on a temporary basis and seek to stay permanently.
Occupations that would lose a longstanding exception
The proposal would end a process known as Schedule A. Under that process, the government has already determined that certain occupations meet the statutory conditions, so employers can forgo the usual test of whether U.S. workers are available for a specific opening. The published proposal identifies professional nurses and physical therapists, plus certain workers of exceptional ability in the sciences or arts, including the performing arts.
The department argues that it should assess worker availability for individual openings rather than rely on an occupational list assembled years ago. It also says it lacks comprehensive information on employers using the exception because they do not file the regular certification applications with its foreign labor office. The proposal summarizes a prior request for public input that drew both calls for expanding Schedule A and objections to keeping it.
For an employer that now relies on Schedule A, the change would add recruitment and labor certification steps to a process that ordinarily proceeds without that individual test. The legal analysis says employers would face longer and more involved procedures if the provision is finalized. For affected workers, the change would concern how the employer sponsors them for permanent residence. It would not itself set a new quota for green cards.
More scrutiny after layoffs
The department also wants more information from employers that have laid off workers. The Labor Department said the proposal would strengthen protections for U.S. workers affected by layoffs. The draft addresses workers supplied through third-party staffing companies as well as those employed directly. It would set standards for how employers report layoffs, giving reviewers a clearer record when an application follows job cuts.
The proposed reporting changes reach beyond any one employer or industry. A company may use a staffing firm for some positions while recruiting directly for others. The rule text sets out how the department would consider that relationship when evaluating a recent layoff. How employers document the positions and workers involved could determine what the agency can test during its review. The department says the goal is to improve evidence that similarly employed U.S. workers were considered.
The proposal would also codify the department’s existing practice of receiving and processing applications electronically. That change addresses how employers submit and receive decisions on certifications and prevailing wage requests. The notice describes it separately from the new duties the agency wants employers to assume.
During the comment period, employers, workers and trade groups can submit evidence about how the changes would work in labor markets with different hiring conditions. The department would then weigh that record before deciding what to finalize. For now, the material changes are proposals: employers looking to sponsor workers face the existing requirements while the agency considers whether to replace the Schedule A process and how to enforce the broader recruiting and layoff provisions. The notice sets out the agency’s rationale and proposed text.