> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.theamericanquorum.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Trump Asks Supreme Court to Limit Judges’ Power to Set Aside Federal Rules
- URL: https://www.theamericanquorum.com/supreme-court-federal-rules-vacatur-surprise-billing/
- Published: 2026-11-15T10:33:23.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-15T10:33:23.000Z
- Description: A dispute over surprise medical billing has put a broader question before the Supreme Court: whether a judge who finds a federal rule unlawful can set it aside for everyone or grant relief only to the parties.
- Author: News Desk
- Tags: US, Texas

The Trump administration is asking the Supreme Court to limit what happens after a federal judge finds an agency rule unlawful. In a case brought by Texas medical providers, the Justice Department argues that courts should generally grant relief only to the people or groups that sued. The [docket](https://www.supremecourt.gov/docket/docketfiles/html/public/26-491.html?ref=theamericanquorum.com) lists two outside briefs submitted Friday and gives the providers until December 14 to respond. The justices have yet to decide whether to hear the case.

The request, reported Saturday by [Reuters](https://www.reuters.com/legal/government/supreme-court-trump-aims-cut-power-judges-again-2026-11-14/?ref=theamericanquorum.com), grows out of a fight over how insurers calculate a payment benchmark under the No Surprises Act. The government’s Supreme Court [petition](https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/26/26-491/429429/20261014091943719%5FTMA%20v.%20HHS%20Petition.pdf?ref=theamericanquorum.com) focuses on the reach of the remedy. It does not ask the justices to decide that the provisions the lower court struck down were lawful. That distinction gives a dispute involving doctors and insurers consequences for federal regulation far beyond health care.

## How a payment rule became a test of judicial power

Congress designed the No Surprises Act to protect patients from unexpected out-of-network charges, including in many emergencies. When the law applies, providers and insurers may still disagree over who should pay the rest of a bill and how much. Under the federal process described in the appeals court’s [opinion](https://litigationtracker.law.georgetown.edu/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/Texas-Medical-Association-v.-HHS%5F2026.08.11%5FOPINION.pdf?ref=theamericanquorum.com), a measure based on insurers’ contracted rates helps determine patient cost sharing and can factor into arbitration over what an insurer owes a provider.

The Texas Medical Association and other challengers disputed what went into that measure, known as the qualifying payment amount. The full Fifth Circuit ruled in August that the federal agencies could not allow insurers to count certain rates for services a provider had not furnished and could not categorically exclude qualifying bonuses and incentive payments from contracted rates. The court upheld a separate rule that excludes certain agreements made for individual patients. [Health Affairs](https://www.healthaffairs.org/content/forefront/fifth-circuit-invalidates-two-more-provisions-of-no-surprises-act-rule?ref=theamericanquorum.com) traced how the full court’s decision changed the result reached by an earlier three-judge panel.

The federal agencies’ [guidance](https://www.cms.gov/initiatives/no-surprise-billing/overview/notices?ref=theamericanquorum.com) shows what the August ruling means for disputes already underway. For arbitrations initiated before the ruling, certified dispute resolution entities should continue to consider the payment amount already supplied alongside other permitted information. The agencies issued that guidance under the existing law. The pending petition concerns the scope of the judgment that set aside parts of the rule, while the patient protections created by Congress remain in place.

## What the government wants the Court to change

Under the Administrative Procedure Act, a reviewing court is directed to hold unlawful and set aside agency action that fails certain legal standards. The Justice Department reads that instruction as allowing judges to disregard an unlawful rule when resolving the case before them. Its [filing](https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/26/26-491/429429/20261014091943719%5FTMA%20v.%20HHS%20Petition.pdf?ref=theamericanquorum.com) argues that lower courts go further when they use the statute to wipe away a rule for everyone affected by it. The Fifth Circuit’s judgment gave the ruling that broader effect.

For someone who never filed suit, the practical difference can be substantial. Under a broadly applicable ruling, other regulated parties can benefit when a court takes a rule out of effect. Under the government’s approach, a company or organization that won relief could be protected while other entities would remain subject to the same rule. An administrative law scholar told [Reuters](https://www.reuters.com/legal/government/supreme-court-trump-aims-cut-power-judges-again-2026-11-14/?ref=theamericanquorum.com) that broader enforcement could continue for years while additional litigation plays out. How long it actually lasted would depend on later rulings and how agencies responded.

The dispute follows the Supreme Court’s June 2025 decision limiting nationwide injunctions in litigation over birthright citizenship. An injunction directs a party to take or refrain from an action. Vacatur, the remedy at issue in the Texas case, sets aside an agency action under the administrative law statute. As [Reuters](https://www.reuters.com/legal/government/supreme-court-trump-aims-cut-power-judges-again-2026-11-14/?ref=theamericanquorum.com) reported, the earlier decision left the statutory question open. A ruling in the Texas case could answer it across a range of challenges to federal agencies.

For providers outside the Texas lawsuit, one question is whether a favorable decision in someone else’s case changes the rules that apply to their own payment disputes. Judge James Ho addressed that issue in a separate [opinion](https://litigationtracker.law.georgetown.edu/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/Texas-Medical-Association-v.-HHS%5F2026.08.11%5FOPINION.pdf?ref=theamericanquorum.com), arguing that the full court should have reconsidered its approach to universal vacatur. His writing illustrates a division within the appeals court over the remedy even though the court issued a judgment setting aside the provisions. The [petition](https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/26/26-491/429429/20261014091943719%5FTMA%20v.%20HHS%20Petition.pdf?ref=theamericanquorum.com) gives the Supreme Court a way to address that division without revisiting the arithmetic of the payment benchmark itself or how insurers negotiate rates with individual providers.

The immediate step is a written response from the Texas providers. Their lawyers sought additional time, and the Court granted the extension in October, according to the [case docket](https://www.supremecourt.gov/docket/docketfiles/html/public/26-491.html?ref=theamericanquorum.com). After briefing, the justices can take up the petition and hear arguments, or leave the Fifth Circuit judgment in place by declining review. Until they act, the appellate judgment and federal guidance remain the relevant public records for insurers and providers handling these billing disputes.